| Espresso Moka Solutions · 0.1.0 | Its own index of every disk, built once and kept on the Mac | Yes: FSEvents, about 16 ms from change to result (measured) | Yes: disks stay searchable after you unplug them (2 in Free, unlimited in Pro) | Yes: hidden files, ~/Library and app contents are indexed, shown when you ask | Full: AND, OR, NOT, wildcards, regex, size, date, kind, folder and duplicate filters | Pro: text in documents (content:) and what photos show (looks:) | Free for personal use; Pro €29 once, every update | macOS 14 Sonoma or later, Apple silicon and Intel |
| Spotlight Apple · built into macOS, tested on 26.3.1 | The system’s Spotlight index of names, metadata and contents | Yes: macOS tells Spotlight about every change | No: only mounted volumes are searched | Partly: in our test it found a file in ~/Library but nothing inside apps and no hidden dotfiles | Partly: attribute rules in Finder, metadata queries in mdfind; no regex | Yes: text and metadata through importers | Free, part of macOS | Every Mac |
| Raycast Raycast Technologies · 2.8 | Its own index of the home folder and Applications (more through search scopes); Spotlight for contents | Yes: the index follows changes, also those made while it was closed | Not documented: it can index network and removable drives | Partly: hidden files are off by default; home folder and Applications unless you add scopes | No: search terms and ignore rules, no operators documented | Yes, through Spotlight | Free; Pro $10 a month or $96 a year | Raycast 2: macOS Tahoe on Apple silicon; also Windows |
| Alfred Running with Crayons · 5.8.1 | Spotlight’s metadata index | Yes, through Spotlight | No: it sees what Spotlight sees | Partly: what Spotlight has indexed | Partly: keywords (open, find, in) and filters you set up | Yes: the “in” keyword, through Spotlight | Free; Powerpack £34 (or £59 with lifetime upgrades) | macOS 10.14 or later |
| HoudahSpot Houdah Software · 6.8.4 | Spotlight’s index (its maker: “if a file isn’t in the Spotlight index, HoudahSpot won’t find it”) | Yes, through Spotlight | No: disks Spotlight hasn’t indexed don’t appear | Partly: what Spotlight has indexed | Yes: nested any/all/none groups, wildcards, a regex filter on results | Yes, through Spotlight | $39 once (every 6.x version) | macOS 10.14 or later |
| Find Any File Thomas Tempelmann · 2.6.1 | No index: it asks the file system at every search | Not applicable: no index; every search reads the disk again | No: a disk must be connected to be searched | Yes: app bundles, /System and /Library, and root mode on local disks | Partly: regex on names and contents; all rules must match | Yes: text, Office and zip files; PDF through Spotlight | $6 direct, $8 on the Mac App Store | macOS 10.11 to 27 |
| EasyFind DEVONtechnologies · 5.0.2, from 2021 | No index: it searches the disk at every search | Not applicable: no index | No: a disk must be connected | Not checked | Yes: Boolean operators, wildcards, phrases, regex | Yes: names, contents, tags and comments | Free | OS X 10.11 or later; last update 5.0.2 (2021) |
| FinderSearch zeusinsight on GitHub · 0.4.9, on fsearch 0.2 | Its own index, built and kept by fsearch | Yes: FSEvents, about 11 ms from change to result (fsearch, measured) | Not documented | Not documented | Partly: fuzzy matching, ext:, mtime:, folder scope | Not yet (listed among its current limits) | Free, open source (MIT) | macOS 15 or later, Apple silicon; not notarized |
| Cling The Low-Tech Guys · 3.3.0 | Its own index of the whole file system | Yes: local changes appear within seconds; network shares are re-indexed periodically | Yes: indexes of unmounted volumes stay searchable | Not documented for name search | Partly: ext:, in:, !, dm:, size:, literal terms | On demand, through Spotlight where available | Free up to 500 results; Pro €15 lifetime | macOS 14 or later |
| NeoFinder Norbert M. Doerner · 9.3.1 | Catalogs: saved snapshots of each disk, updated when you ask | No: catalogs are updated by hand or on a schedule (the schedule isn’t in the Private licence) | Yes: its core purpose, including optical discs and LTO tapes | Not checked | Partly: a Find editor and smart folders | Partly: contents of text files in catalogs | $39.99 once (Private licence, 3 Macs) | macOS 10.15 or later |
| ProFind Zero One Twenty · 1.42 | Its own search, with an optional cache of names, sizes and dates; Spotlight for metadata searches | Not documented | Yes: disks you cached | Not checked | Yes: AND, OR, NOT with parentheses, regex, wildcards | Yes: PDF, Word, RTF, archives; optional OCR | $6.99 | macOS 11 or later |